Abstract
This paper provides a thorough
knowledge about the role of women in the military.
The role of women in the military began with the
revolutionary war in which they helped the military
by cooking, chopping firewood, building shelters
and nursing wounded or ill men back to health.
Then women took part in the war of 1812 and the
Mexico-American war but they were not eligible
for combat duties. During the Civil war, women
again served in quasi-military status without
benefit of rank or veterans' benefits.
They worked as nurses and helped
in providing food. Some of the women also performed
combat duties. During the Spanish-American war,
for the first time in the Army's history, large
numbers of women were hired to serve as contract
nurses in military hospitals.
During World War I, first time the
women were allowed to serve in the military on
the non-nursing positions. Since then, the number
of women in military is increasing. During the
Gulf war 1991, women were not allowed to perform
combat duties but since 1994, 90 % of the women
have given assignments that involve combat duties.
Women in the Military
The Revolutionary War
During the American Revolution, the Army was
a nearly all-male institution. Most soldiers were
young, and more than a few were just boys. Officially,
the Army was a racially exclusive institution.
The majority of soldiers were white. However,
despite the continued reliance on white males,
mom than 5,000 black men fought in the Army or
militia during the Revolutionary War.
Several hundred more served in the Navy. (Millis,
1957) The war's exigencies also caused a breach
in the gender line. By war's end in 1783, more
than 20,000 women had provided support, sustenance
or active service for the military. Although not
officially part of the military, women were vital
contributors to its success. (Abrahamson, 1983)
They helped hold the Army together.
The Army was the heart of the resistance and
was crucial to the patriots' cause. Yet desertion
was one of the greatest challenges troop Commander
George Washington faced. Lengthy periods of deprivation,
insufficient food and inadequate clothing and
footwear were the most frequent causes of desertion.
During the bleak winter at Valley Forge, desertions
reached crisis proportions.
During a particularly dismal period, several
large wagons filled with foodstuffs arrived. Ten
women had braved the elements and poor roads to
deliver tons of precious supplies to the beleaguered
Army. (Fowler, 1995) Women helped stem the tide
of desertions by cooking, chopping firewood, building
shelters and nursing wounded or ill men back to
health. Washington once remarked that: without
the Army's women, many more men would have deserted.
(Mahon, 1983)
For the women who accompanied the Army, life
was difficult and dangerous. Little or no provision
was made for them. They typically relied on their
husband-soldiers for support. Sometimes they were
allowed to ride in the baggage wagons, but few
other concessions were granted them. (Hymowitz
& Weissman, 1978)
Few women served directly as combatants. However,
some did fight from necessity or choice. Some
women did not wait for fate to provide an opportunity
for combat. Many women disguised themselves as
men in order to fight. The war presented its own
special challenges for the women who remained
at home. Local governments typically failed to
provide fix the relief of soldiers' wives and
children, which put the burden of maintaining
the household exclusively on the women.
Circumstance forced some women to request their
husbands' and sons' return. In 1778, one soldier's
wife wrote, "[We are] without bread, &
cannot get any, the Committee will not supply
me, my children will starve, or if they win not,
they will freeze, we have no wood, neither can
we get any--Pray Come Home."(Cometti, 1947)
As the Revolution continued, the Army expended
large quantities of gunpowder and small-areas
cartridges. From 1779 to 1780, the commissary
general hired men and women to make musket cartridges.
Women combined domestic and munitions work by
working at home, while men worked in the laboratories.
The quality of the women's efforts was excellent,
as their manual dexterity enabled them to make
superior cartridges. (Risch, 1981)
Post-Revolutionary Period
After the war's end, many of the women had made
were lost. They found few work opportunities existed
outside the home. Cultural pressures continued
to determine occupational roles. (Mintz &
Kellogg, 1988) On the frontier, necessity continued
to dismantle social distinctions between the sexes.
Frontier women had to load muskets and fight with
shot or club. Effective survival precluded the
luxury of social constructs.
In November 1791, St. Clair left Fort Washington
with 2,700 men accompanied by 200 women. St. Clair's
army was mostly composed of inexperienced militiamen,
many of whom fled when the Indians attacked. The
remainder fought as best as they could, with the
women fighting alongside. (Coffman, 1986) St.
Clair's defeat stood as the worst disaster in
American arms until the Battle of the Little Big
Horn in 1876. one--third of St. ClaWs force was
killed or captured. All but a few of the women
died in the fighting, or, if captured, were, like
the men, tortured to death by their captors.
War of 1812
More than 527,000 men served in the militia
during the War of 1812. The regular Army remained
a tiny group of 6,700 men. Few women served with
the military in any official capacity. As always,
there were exceptions to this general rule. (Willenz,
1983) For some women, involvement in combat was
not a matter of choice.
Seeking protection for themselves and their families,
women were sometimes forced to seek shelter in
Army forts. When forts were attacked, the women
automatically became part of the defending garrison.
In some cases when the fort fell, the women shared
the fate of the soldiers--death or capture.
War-with Mexico
Women figured in the Mexican--American War early
on. On 3 May 1846, after President James Polk
sent troops into South Texas, the Mexican army
crossed the Rio Grande, entered the disputed area
and placed Fort Texas under siege. Captain Edgar
Hawkins led the fort's defense. Women who had
taken shelter at the fort provided essential support
dining the siege.
For three days, they loaded muskets, put out
fires and tended the wounded. When the siege was
lifted, General Zachary Taylor made Sarah Borginis
a brevet colonel for her singular participation
in the defense of the fort.
Civil War
In a manner that paralleled past and future
practices, the larger the scale and the longer
the duration of a war, the more military leaders
looked to women as a resource when manpower ran
low. During the Civil War necessity again rather
than equality created women's roles. Women again
served in quasi-military status without benefit
of rank or veterans' benefits.
Thousands of women (and even children) worked
in government--owned arsenals and armories, helping
to manufacture substantial amounts of munitions.
To match the insatiable demand for munitions,
work shifts often began at 6:30 a.m. and ended
at 10:30 p.m., seven days a week. (Murray &
Swantek, 1993) Between 1861 and 1865, more than
100,000 women became involved in wartime factory
work.
Women also expanded their influence in medical
support services and relief efforts. They served
as nurses and organized efforts to provide food
and clothing to soldiers. They also helped reduce
the suffering of combatants and displaced refugees.
Early in the war, more than 3,000 New York women
provided medical support and nursing services
for sick soldiers.
The Women's Central Association led to the establishment,
in 1861, of the US Sanitary Commission. Under
Superintendent Dorothea Dix's excellent leadership,
the commission coordinated Union soldiers' care,
staffed and supplied hospitals and organized transport
for the wounded. The women received little monetary
compensation. The Sanitary Commission's Field
Relief Corps workers received $12 a month, for
which they toiled day and night to relieve the
agony and general discomfort of sick and wounded
men. (Brocket, 1993)
The challenges Northern women faced were truly
horrific, but Southern women lived through even
more horrors. During the Civil War, some women
completely broke with tradition, taking on combat
roles. Madame Truchin, a Russian army officer's
daughter, had been raised in military camps. At
an early age, she developed an excellent knowledge
of the profession of arms. Married to an American
Army colonel, Truchin chose to remain with him
when his troops marched to Tennessee.
Colonel Truchin was taken seriously ill, and
during his convalescence, Madame Truchin assumed
his responsibilities and served as the regiment's
acting commander. The men obeyed her commands,
and in the battles that followed, she sometimes
led the men in attack. On the battlefield, her
actions were reputedly courageous, even when she
was subjected to the heaviest of enemy fire. After
the Civil War, the Army rapidly demobilized. During
the post-Civil War years, thousands of women joined
their husband-soldiers, who were assigned constabulary
duties in the trans-Mississippi West.
The government made no provision for either married
or single women. Poorer women earned part of their
living by mending uniforms or serving as washerwomen.
Many women had only a soldier friend's or husband's
support on which to rely. (Rickey, 1963) The husband--soldiers'
fates were always in question when troops went
into Indian territory. However, those left behind
also faced fear and uncertainty. Some women were
given pistols and instructed to shoot themselves
and their children if attacking Indians overran
the fort. (Rickey, 1963)
Despite the bonds resulting from shared hardship
on army posts, the women (and men) were split
by class. Officers' wives conducted themselves
as Victorian ladies. Enlisted men's wives and
other working-class women endured poor pay and
low status. Interaction between the clasps was
generally formal, reflecting distinct social ordering.
Officers' wives often adopted their husbands'
ranks, wielding them like a social pedigree. However,
even for officers' wives, frontier life was harsh
and dangerous.
Spanish-American War
By the late 1890s, women's efforts to improve
their political status were gaining momentum.
Suffrage associations were waging state campaigns.
Utah and Wyoming had already enfranchised women,
and the Women's Christian Temperance Union was
attracting thousands of new members. (Echols,
1991)
In the military, as in larger civil society,
women made incremental progress toward equality
with men. Long-standing traditions that allowed
women to enter the male world of the military
only in times of dire crisis were changing. In
1897, the Missouri National Guard instituted a
unique program that allowed women students of
the state university to organize a company of
coeds. A regular Army officer trained the company.
One officer; Enoch Crowder; even allowed the women
to perform close order drill without their corsets.
The Spanish-American War created a substantial
need for military nurses. Early in the war, an
epidemic of typhoid fever broke out in Army camps.
While combat claimed 365 lives, typhoid claimed
thousands. As well as claiming soldiers' lives,
typhoid caused a severe shortage of male nurses.
Once again, necessity, overriding tradition, gave
women the opportunity to support the military.
(O’Toole, 1984) For the first time in the
Army's history, large numbers of women were hired
to serve as contract nurses in military hospitals.
By September 1898, more than 1,100 women were
working in wards overseas and in the United States.
Dr. Anita Newcomb McGee became the nurses' bureau
chief. Despite the influx of nurses, the full
benefit of this innovation was not felt until
Army hospitals approached a state of collapse.
(Cosmas, 1971) Once deployed, the nurses fell
victim to the same conditions as the suffering
men. Many contracted typhoid, and more than 12
nurses died.
Post-Spanish-American War Period
Largely as a result of the excellent service
nurses provided during the Spanish-American War,
Army and Navy leaders finally took steps to officially
include women in the American military. Congress
established the Army nurse corps, as an auxiliary,
in 1901. The Navy followed the Army's example
seven years later.
The impact was to make military nursing a virtual
feminine monopoly for several decades.( Seeley
et al, 1992) These initiatives validated the need
for women in the military but still did not grant
them full military status. Women nurses were without
rank or equivalent pay scales. They also lacked
military retirement rights and other benefits
normally granted to male veterans.
World War I
World War I was the first war during which American
women were officially allowed to serve in non-nursing
positions. Driven by necessity and anticipating
a shortfall in the numbers of young men available
for active service, Secretary of the Navy Josephus
Daniels directed the recruitment of women for
the position of yeoman.
Women were also allowed to perform clerical duties,
which men had traditionally accomplished. This
action had the dual effect of improving administrative
support for the Navy and of freeing a sizable
number of men for sea duty. The Marine Corps liked
the idea and began its own program in 1918. However,
the only women allowed to join the Army were nurses.
In 1918, Commander in Chief, American Expeditionary
Forces, General John J. Pershing, cabled the US
War Department requesting 1,500 nurses be sent
to France at the earliest practicable date. Army
personnel were experiencing a severe outbreak
of influenza, and by October, nearly 70,000 soldiers
bad developed a severe form of pneumonia. The
death rate among the Americans rose to 32 percent
of all reported casualties and accounted for 80
percent of deaths in some American combat units.
(Pershing, 1931)
Pershing reported on the outstanding service provided
by both male and female nurses: In many instances
they were under constant exposure on or near the
battlefields for long periods. Their supply track
trains and ambulance trains went back and forth
at all times, and were often hit by artillery. More
than 10,000 women military nurses served overseas
in World War I and over 34,000 women had served
in the Army, Navy, Marines or Coast Guard. Three
women received the Distinguished Service Cross,
and 23 received the Distinguished Service Medal.
Thirty-eight died in military service overseas,
mostly from illness.
Opportunities and Risks for Women in
Military
Women are serving in greater numbers and are
also closer to the frontlines of combat than they
have been in previous wars. Women were restricted
from participating in direct combat in the first
Gulf War in 1991. But since 1994, more than 90
percent of service positions, which includes most
combat assignments, have been open to women. According
to the U.S. Department of Defense, there are about
140,000 women serving as officers and enlisted
personnel in the U.S. military.
Women represent 16 percent of the enlisted population
in the Army, 14 percent in the Navy, 19 percent
in the Air Force and 6 percent in the Marines.
Black women represent 41.7 percent of enlisted
women in the Army -- the largest percentage of
any other group. (Devilbiss, 1990)
The Army is a great place for women, [particularly]
African American women, to serve their country.
Regardless of its warts, the Army has done a Herculean
job to ensure that people are advanced on merit,
not gender or race. Since the American Revolution
(1775-1783) women have served in the military
in traditional roles as nurses and performing
domestic duties, but also as spies. During the
Revolutionary War and the Civil War, it is believed
that some women disguised themselves as male soldiers
to fight on the frontlines.
There is no documentation of Black women's military
service in the Revolutionary War, but according
to officials from the Women in Military Service
for America Memorial at Arlington National Cemetery,
they may have served alongside Black men. Records
do show that free Black women served during the
Civil War as nurses, laundresses and cooks. Although
they served in traditional roles, women found
themselves in harm's way early on. (Karen, 1988)
During World War II, 88 nurses were held as
POWs. There were also over 200 women killed by
hostile fire in World War. According to Manning
the Iraq war has been a victory for women. Thousands
of women are over there and every one of them
has gone above and beyond the call of duty --
they've done their jobs, they've done them as
well as the men, and the three women who were
in 507 Maintenance handled themselves very bravely.
it is found disturbing that women, particularly
mothers separated for long periods from their
children, are serving at far greater risk. The
fact that three of the women were captured...to
one it is not a step forward for women it is a
step backwards for civilization. (Elshtain, 1987)
For more than two centuries there have been many
achievements for women in the military. many women
still don't see how they fit into military history.
It takes a while for them to realize what they
did is important. It's a wonderful story of service,
sacrifice and pride that is just now bubbling
forth to the top.
Women and Combat Duties
The issue: whether women should be allowed to
take up arms on the brutal front lines of combat.
Opponents contend that allowing women into combat
positions will undermine the readiness of forces,
threaten national security, and tear at the nation's
social fabric by officially condoning violence
against women. Supporters counter that women who
meet all of the qualifications for combat will
simply enhance their units' readiness, as they
have in other divisions of the military. And that
success, they argue, will help enhance the societal
view of women as leaders and fighters, instead
of victims, in a culture where violence is prevalent.
(Elshtain, 1988)
Gender Makeup of Services
Women now make up about 14 percent of the nation's
500,000 Army personnel. As fewer men enlist, the
Army is banking on attracting more women to fill
the gap. But many young recruits and career women
say they enter with a disadvantage: They're excluded
from ground combat service in the infantry, armor,
and artillery branches, traditionally the paths
top military leaders have taken as they move up
the ranks. To defenders of the status quo, that
exclusion is the last beachhead protecting the
unique "warrior spirit" necessary to
an effective, cohesive combat unit. (Forcey, 1991)
Women have proved that they can do what they
want if chances are given. Their role in the military
has changed from nursing to non-nursing and now
they are performing combat duties. Time has come
to realize their efforts and ambitions.
References
W. Millis, 1957. Arms and Men: A Study in American
Military History (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University
Press,), 23-24, 35
J.L. Abrahamson, 1983. The American Home Front
(Washington, DC: National Defense University Press),
9.
William W. Fowler, 1995. Frontier Women: An Authentic
History of the Courage and Trials of Pioneer Heroines
of Our American Frontier (Stamford, NY: Longmeadow
Press), 136-37.
Abrahamson; J.K. Mahon, 1983. History of the Militia
and the National Guard (New York: Macmillan),
43.
Carol Hymowitz and Michaele Weissman, 1978. A
History of Women in America (New York: Bantam
Books), 29; Millett and Maslowski, 57.
Elizabeth Cometti, 1947. Women in the American
Revolution," New England Quarterly (September
1947), 330; Abrahamson, 6.
S. Mintz and S. Kellogg, Domestic Revolutions:
A Social History of American Family Life (Now
York: The Free Press), 49-51.
E. Coffman, 1988. The Old Army: A Portrait of
the American Army in Peacetime, 1784-1898 (New
York: Oxford University Press, 1986), 26; Mahon,
50-51.
J.A. Willenz, 1983. Women Veterans: America's
Forgotten Heroines (Now York: Continuum Publishing
Company,), 12
J.V. Murray and J. Swantek, 1813-1993. ed. The
Watervliet Arsenal (Watervliet, NY: Public Affairs
Office), 97-98, 101.
L.P. Brocket, 1993. Women at War: A Record of
Their Path Contributions, Heroism, Toils and Sacrifice
During The Civil War (Woodbury, CT: Platinum Press.
Originally published in 1868); Swisshelm, 180-81.
D. Rickey, 1963. Forty Miles a Day on Beans and
Hay (Normen, OK: University of Oklahoma Press,),
28.
Alice Echols, 1991. "Feminist Movement,"
The Reader's Companion to American History, Eric
Foner and John A. Garraty, ed (Boston, MA: Houghton
Mifflin Company), 392.
G.J.A. O'Toole, 1984. The Spanish War: An American
Epic 1898 (New York: W.W. Norton Company), 375.
G.A. Cosmas, 1971. An Army for Empire: The United
States Army in the Spanish-American War (Columbia,
MO: University of Missouri Press), 294.
J.J. Pershing, 1931. My Experiences in the World
War (New York: Frederick A. Stokes Company), 327.
Devilbiss, M.C. 1990. Women and Military Service:
A History, Analysis, and Overview of Key Issues.
Maxwell Air Force Base, Alabama: Air University
Press.
Dunivin, Karen O. 1988. "There's Men, There's
Women, and There's Me: The Role and Status of
Military Women." Minerva: Quarterly Report
on Women and the Military 6:43-68.
Elshtain, Jean Bethke. 1987, Women and War. New
York: Basic Books. Enloe, Cynthia. 1980, "Women--The
Reserve Army of Army Labor." The Review of
Radical Political Economics 12:42-52.
-----------------------. 1988. "United States."
In Women and the Military System, ed. Eva Isaksson.
New York: St. Martin's Press.
Forcey, Linda Rennie. 1991. "The Gender Question
in the Peace Studies Classroom." NWSAction
4:4.
|